top of page
Search

Fooling the Big Chief

Writer: Crazy Socks
Crazy Socks
Oct 2
12 min read

Updated: Oct 10

Bilodeau Review

 

1.    The Bilodeau Review was published by Mr. Michel Bilodeau on January 23, 2018 and provided to the Grand Chief of the Mushkegowuk Territory Mr. Jonathon Solomon and his Council. Shortly thereafter, it was published on the Ministry of Health & Long-Term Care ("MOHLTC") website until the early part of 2024.  It no longer exists and all efforts to find it have been unsuccessful.  These efforts include information technology exchanges to the Ministry of Health and Archives Ontario, the WAHA including the CEO Ms. Lynne Innes and Chief of Staff Elaine Innes by many people, and by the 4 investigators that I know of by name (Ms. Fyfe, Dr. Preston, Mr. McNeil & Mr. Bilodeau).  Phone calls to the MOHLTC are impossible given the endless automated messages offered.

 

2.    What prompted its disappearance was a blog titled ‘Fooling the Big Chief’ posted on my website www.mushkegowuklivesmatter.net about February 2024 that was viewed by several hundred patients from the WAHA.  In this blog, I outlined how the Bilodeau Review was a blatant scam as will be outlined below. It generated some grassroots winds of discontent that blew to the WAHA but also likely found its way to other places, and the next thing you know the Bilodeau Review is gone; burying the evidence if I may say so.

 

3.    The bulk of the 10 – page Bilodeau Review consists of well-established old news borrowed from other previous documents that everyone knew about, and then repackaged to look like 'new' news. This now 'new' news was known by everyone for a couple of decades and included:

 

  • The WAHA’s patients & family members,

  • The local elected leaders,

  • The local health leaders,

  • The doctors, surgeons, anesthetists, specialists, dentists, hygienists, other allied health professionals, technicians and technologists that worked at the WAHA,

  • The referral centres,

  • The teaching centres,

  • The MOHLTC, and

  • Health Canada.

 

4.    I quickly came to know of the 'new' news contained within the Bilodeau Review upon my arrival to the area in 2005.

 

5.    Mr. Bilodeau’s Review ascribed the issues and challenges faced in the WAHA to external factors such as:

 

  • Rundown buildings;

  • Antiquated equipment and lack of equipment;

  • Obsolete IT and phone systems;

  • Transportation issues moving patients, doctors and other staff about the Territory;

  • Lack of specialty equipment; and

  • A focus on acute care, rather than primary and preventive care (this will be discussed in detail as to how this came to be later on in this document.


 

6.    In all cases of the egregious misconduct and corruption within the WAHA that I knew of, none of it was caused by old buildings, antiquated equipment or obsolete IT and phones, et cetera.

 

7.    Instead, all of the issues related to significant personnel issues in the Medical Staff and poor management that I had reported to many people in many places for an extended period of time.   

 

8.    To deal with my allegations on Facebook and contained within the Grand Chief’s letters these three lines of deceit were intentionally inserted into the Bilodeau Review.  They read:

 

i)               ‘The nine members of the team were unanimous in their assessments that physicians and staff are dedicated, hardworking, competent and generally do what they do well’;

 

ii)             We also found that the hospital had the right systems in place to monitor quality of care, provide quality care and ensure patient safety’; and

 

iii)            ‘We did not find any area of serious concern with the care provided’.

 

9.     I know the names of 4 of the 9 investigators, three of which are not physicians.  Physicians’ skills and knowledge are not determined by investigative panels or non-physicians.  The process is called Peer and Practice Assessment.  Its highlights include:

 

i)            It is performed by the College of Physicians & Surgeons of Ontario ("CPSO") as this organization has a legal and professional obligation to ensure that the physicians they license are both skilled and knowledgeable, as described in the Regulated Professional Health Act, CPSO Essentials of Medical Professionalism and the CPSO Practice Guidelines;

ii)             All peer assessors are licensed physicians in Ontario;

iii)           All peer assessors are carefully chosen by the CPSO;

iv)           All peer assessors are highly trained by the CPSO;

v)      All peer assessors’ skills and knowledge are matched to the practice of the assessed physician.  In the WAHA case, the physicians provide emergency room, obstetric, hospitalist, primary care and some administrative duties to run a hospital.  Given this, a suitable peer assessor’s practice would involve the same services; 

vi)            All peer assessors examine many of the assessed physician’s medical records, and in doing this assessment use a standardized template;

vii)          All peer assessors interview the assessed physician;

viii)      All peer assessors never interview patients or any other person aside from the assessed physician;

ix)            Peer assessors take ½ to an entire day to complete their assessment;

x)       After this, a peer assessor submits a written report to the CPSO’s Quality Assurance Committee;

xi)        It is the QAC that makes the decision as to the skills and knowledge of the assessed physician, not the peer assessor;

xii)          There are 4 outcomes issued by the QAC to grade an assessed physician’s skills and knowledge, they are:

 

  • Satisfactory,

  • Opportunity to address the QAC’s concerns,

  • Peer & practice reassessment, and

  • Notice of Intent to take action under HPPC 80.2(1).

 

xiii)         These outcomes are mailed to the assessed physicians within 10 weeks from the initial assessment.

xiv)         Peer & practice assessments are never made public; and

xv)          Peer and practice assessments are not a delegable act, that is they can only be performed by physicians.


A link to the CPSO Peer Assessment is formally described in my post titled "How doctors are really assessed'.

     

10.  At the time of the 3 – day investigation on October 31, November 1 and November 2, 2017, there were at least 33 family doctors working at the WAHA that included:  Banayan, Barkman, Bond, Dahl, Gao, Gillies, Green, Innes, Jaffer, Kading, Klassen, Leung, Lusher, MacMillan, Malcolm, Martens, Mawamenda, McNeil, Muselius, Nicholson, Nevins, Ngai, Peltier, Perera, Salehi, Sebastian Sheik, Shoucri, Thompson, Waddell, Wang, Whyte & Winterburn.

 

11. The peer and practice assessment process outlined above was not done by any of the 9 – member investigative team which renders this statement meaningless to a knowing audience.

 

‘The nine members of the team were unanimous in their assessments that physicians and staff are dedicated, hardworking, competent and generally do what they do well.’ 

 

But to an unknowing audience, it was written with the intent to deceive the Grand Chief, his Council and all of the patients of WAHA.     

 

12. To the next line, that reads:

 

‘We also found that the hospital had the right systems in place to monitor quality of care, provide quality care and ensure patient safety.’

 

On paper this is true but in practice many doctors, nurses and senior executives know this to be false.  If they had interviewed me, I would have told them my experience with quality of care and its monitoring using these examples:

 

  • Patients discharged from hospital to their home communities with no discharge notes,

  • Patients discharged from hospital with no means to follow prescribed treatment program which was most common with patients with diabetic feet complications,

  • Medication Error Reporting Forms stacked by the dozens unattended on the desk in the charge nurse’s office and never processed through the Pharmacy & Therapeutic Committee,

  • Physicians continued charting on paper for years past the implementation of the Electronic Medical Records as it was more convenient,

  • An accuracy rate of 50 percent in the Cumulative Patient Profile medication list section, to which the Dr. Martens was satisfied with,

  • Inadequate physician-to-physician handover of ER patients transferred to the ward for care especially admissions during the night shift,

  • Thousands of lab results left unattended in the Lab Director’s office for months,

  • Hundreds of specialists’ reports left unattended in the WAHA electronic medical records for months,

  • Inadequate vetting of appointments and reappointments,

  • Intentional circumventing and manipulation of established WAHA rules, regulations, policies and Bylaws, as well as various provincial laws,

  • No mortality rounds held by the Medical Staff ever,

  • No mock drills for any emergencies and,

  • No annual performance reviews of any physician done by any hospital Chief despite the Bylaws prescribing that they be part of the reappointment criterion (Section 15.1(1) and 15.1(3)(a)).

 

To an unknowing audience this second line is knowingly misleading in that it is falsely reassuring meant to deceive the Grand Chief, his Council and the WAHA patients. 

 

13. To the third line that reads:

 

‘We did not find any area of serious concern with the care provided.’

 

The reason why this is so, is the 9 – member investigative team knowingly looked away from me who was furiously waving giant red flags of warning to many people over an extended period of time internally, externally and finally on Facebook. These people include:

 

At the WAHA:

 

  • Chief of Staff Dr. Green,

  • Chief of Family Medicine Dr. Ben Martens,

  • President of the Medical Staff Dr. Zahra Jaffer,

  • President of the Medical Staff Dr. Arnold Hill,,

  • Chief of Staff Dr. Marlyn Cooke,

  • Chief of Family Medicine Dr. Michael Ouellette,

  • CEO Mr. Bernie Schmidt,

  • Chairman of the Board Mr. Leo Loone,

  • VP HR Ms. Kelly Reuben,

  • Chief Quality Officer Ms. Caroline Lidstone – Jones,

  • Quality Coordinator Mr. Robert Gagnon,

  • Chief Privacy Officer Ms. Janice Soltys;

  • WAHA lawyer Ms. Kate Dewhirst;

  • The offending physician themselves,

  • The Medical Advisory Committee (“MAC”),

  • The Board of Directors,

  • amongst others.

 

At the CPSO:

 

  • Mr. Matthew MacKenzie – intake worker,

  • Ms. Elaine Stone – investigator,

  • Ms. Svetlana Goltsman - investigator,

  • Ms. Ann Atkinson - investigator,

  • Ms. Melanie Carrington - investigator,

  • and the above listed people’s reports were seen by several of CPSO physicians and a couple members of the public that work for the CPSO, and

  • Registrar Dr. Nancy Whitmore.

 

At the Information Privacy Commission of Ontario (“IPCO”)

 

i)               Mr. Frank Russo

 

At the Mushkegowuk Tribal Council Grand Chief

 

i)               Mr. Jonathon Solomon

 

My contact information was held by many at the WAHA and the CPSO.  My LinkedIn account has my email address. I have Messenger on my Facebook account. The Grand Chief had my phone number and email address. There is no valid excuse as to why the investigators should not have spoken to me.  


If they had spoken to me, I am unequivocally positive that they would have found my testimony and corroborating documentation to be compelling and credible when describing the egregious, disgraceful and corrupt misdeeds committed by many within the WAHA as described in detail in my blog titled 'Dirty Deeds Done by Docs'.

 

 

Dr. Preston's Review

 

14. I also pointed out the shortcomings in the Preston Review in ‘Fooling the Big Chief.’

 

It was mostly a copy-and-paste exercise of a report that had been completed in 2016 by himself, Mr. McNeil, NE LHIN CEO Ms. Louise Paquette and NE LHIN Primary Care Lead Dr. Jason Sutherland.  In a similar fashion as the Bilodeau Review it was well established ‘new’ news Review with one carefully inserted line in a 7 - page document, highlighted and in its own paragraph that read:

 

‘Despite all this, the physicians have persevered and do an excellent job, and are to be commended for the work they do in such circumstances.’ 

 

In the Preston Review, he interviewed only Drs. Green and Martens when there were at least 33 members of the Medical Staff.  To a knowing person (a licensed physician in Ontario), this sentence is meaningless for the same reasons outlined in the section titled ‘Bilodeau Review’ as his determination did not satisfy the criterion of a CPSO Peer & Practice Assessment. 


Like the other 8 investigators, Dr. Preston was not qualified to perform Peer Assessments on 2 members of the Medical Staff, let alone 33. In order to do this a minimum of 16.5 days of investigation would have been required, not just 3.


Examination of Dr. Preston's public expense report he was never in the Mushkegowuk Territory in 2017. How he conducted a 3-day onsite investigation as he claims in his Review of the operations of WAHA located in the Territory defies any explanation other

 

Dr. Preston’s Review was introduced into evidence at my Health Professions Appeal & Review Board (“HPARB”) appeal hearing by Dr. Green’s legal team of three lawyers, and to this unknowing audience (the three non-physician panel members of the HPARB) coupled with the twists and turns of an unscrupulous 3-member legal team, it deceived them, as seen in their Decision with Reasons, that reads in part:

 

“152. The Appeal Board finds that Dr. Waddell’s conduct in the above social media postings to clearly demonstrate his continued inability to conduct himself in a fashion that might demonstrate co-operation with the Board or WAHA’s leadership. His multiple misleading and serious allegations against WAHA, its employees and its staff based on incidents that took place many years ago, including incidents that would have occurred while Dr. Waddell was in a position of administration and leadership. The posts, while problematic for many reasons, are particularly concerning given the impression Dr. Waddell is conveying to the public that the incidents are current issues in the community despite the fact that these events occurred some years ago and are stated according to Dr. Waddell’s perspective and may not be accurate. Indeed, Dr. Waddell has not been onsite at WAHA or provided direct on-site physician services to WAHA’s patients since 2014. Dr. Waddell has not provided any physician services, such as Coastal Call consultation services, to WAHA since March 2015. 

 

153. The entire Facebook campaign is highly inappropriate and contrary to Dr. Waddell’s obligations to the hospital which he was seeking privileges in and which had previously granted him privileges. This is not the way to deal with complaints, well-founded, or in this case, otherwise.” 

 

Based on the underlined sentences, it is my impression that the 3–member panel feels that my Facebook allegations are untrue. 

 

At no time in the hearing was my Facebook allegations scrutinized in any way of examination and cross examination.  No patient charts were examined.  No witnesses that could corroborate my allegations were present.  No Human Resources files or relevant emails were presented.  Dr. Preston was not even in attendance to attest to his assessment and there was no evidence that it was a certified copy of his original document. 

 

In addition, the only purpose of my HPARB hearing was to determine if I was to be reappointed or not to the Medical Staff at the WAHA.  At no time in the hearing did any panel member, lawyer or other participant indicate to me or my lawyer that another purpose was to be added, that being to determine the merits of my Facebook allegations. 

 

In fact, in Volumes 1 to 7 of the evidence used at my HPARB hearing is good evidence to support my Facebook allegations titled:

 

i)               The Sewage which describes Dr. Louise Sewell’s destruction of the medical record of an Elder admitted into the WAHA because she misdiagnosed the patient’s myocardial infarction thus denying her timely and appropriate cardiac care.  There are corroborating documents and witnesses available to verify this.

  

ii)             Over the Hill which describes Dr. Hill’s return to obstetrics after a 30 – year period having received no retraining or recertification.  The delivery went horribly wrong and the baby boy was in harm’s way but by the grace of God and the steady hands of others the boy was born healthy and well, but the mother was seriously injured by receiving an outdated and unnecessary procedure without anesthetic. 

 

 

iii)            The Loon with the Crooked Beak chronicles Mr. Loon’s failures as Chairman of the Board to allow a physician back onto the Medical Staff with a deplorable work record, Dr. Fred Barkman (“Dr. Barkman”). 

 

 

iv)            Dr. Barkman whose record at the WAHA was documented in Volumes 1 to 7 that the HPARB panel had access to demonstrated:

 

·      Insubordination;

·      Dereliction of duty;

·      Ignoring an emergency hospital temporary policy;

·      Violating the Confidentiality Agreement;

·      Workplace violence;

·      Acts of blatant conflicts of interest;

·      Threats to abandon patients, and an actual act of patient abandonment;

·      Amongst others.

 

Although not in the Volumes 1 to 7 was Dr. Barkman ignoring WAHA policy by delivering a high-risk pregnancy at the WGH site that caused catastrophic and permanent injuries to a baby in 2013; a fact known by Dr. Green, Dr. Martens, Dr. Jaffer and many others at the WAHA.  In 2025, it was determined that he failed to meet the standard of practice with a sizeable award given out to the plaintiffs including the maimed child. 


 

15. Another section that is misleading in Preston’s Review reads:

 

‘The existing model of PC [Primary Care] delivery has been inherited, passed down from previous iterations of groups of physicians practicing in the area over many decades……..It is clearly rooted in an old system developed to provide Acute Care (AC) services, namely hospital based Emergency Room (ER), Hospitalist care of inpatients and Obstetrical Care.  Consequently, these services constitute the bulk of PC services currently provided.’  

 

This is not true.  In August 2007, the Weeneebayko Area Health Integration Framework Agreement (“WAHIFA”) was signed off by 5 area Chiefs, a Mayor, the Minister of Health Canada and the Minister of MOHLTC. 

 

There was an Addendum to the WAHIFA that was negotiated with the signatories plus the Chief of Staff at the time Dr. Murray Trusler.  In that Addendum was the list of services the family physicians shall provide that includes,

 

  • Staffing the ER 24 hours a day for 365 days a year,

  • Tending to hospitalized patients admitted to Weeneebayko General Hospital and the two sites of the James Bay General Hospital located in Fort Albany and Attawapiskat,

  • To provide low-risk obstetrical services to the expecting mothers,

  • Administrative duties as required by the Bylaws and various laws in Ontario, and

  • To provide primary care in coastal communities by physicians from the hospital as follows:

 

·      Peawanuck 6 days a month;

·      Attawapiskat 24 days per month;

·      Kashechewan 20 days per month;

·      Fort Albany 16 days per month; and

·      Moosonee 21 days per month.

 

In every physicians’ contract is a provision that they will participate in these coastal visits.   

 

Upon taking over the Chief of Staff position the above was explained to Dr. Green in his 2 – day orientation that I provided to him on June 1 & 2, 2013.  Within a few months of this and without consultation with any of the signatories, Dr. Green markedly cut coastal services.

 

At the time of cutting coastal visits, these were the volumes of hospital – based care the previous year:

 

i)               ER saw on average 23 patients per day.  The vast majority were minor health issues;

 

ii)             The obstetric family doctor delivered on average 2 babies per week; and

 

iii)            The hospitalist handled 2 – 3 admissions per day.

 

 

This works out to 27 patients per day, which translates to just over 1 patient per hour split between 4 doctors.

 

Based on my 15 years in practice before coming to WAHA, I saw by myself about 30 patients per 8 – hour day.

 

Dr. Green’s cuts lessened the already very low physician workload and increased the length of the waiting lists to see the doctors in the communities.  In my view, this is purposeful systematic neglect of the patients who live in coastal communities.




Dr. John Waddell, M.D. (retired)

 

 

 
 
 

Comments


​

​

©2020 by Mushkegowuk Health. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page